Discussion about this post

User's avatar
ann k's avatar

Bill this is excellent work and i agree w your list…looking forward to more as your expand on each. Of particular interest to me is the question of what precisely breaks college students of their faith. It seems to me to possibly be breaking of habit versus and outright intellectual assault. Thanks for the article.

Expand full comment
Epistle of Dude's avatar

"Woke ideology is not a betrayal of scientific materialism but its logical conclusion."

Great post, Dr. Dembski! :)

I want to add that I fear it's not a remote possibility that, in turn, woke ideology could become totalitarian if given the right opportunity.

In this respect, there's something to be said for the connection between the evolutionary materialism of people like Dawkins, widely shared by the Western intelligentsia today, and totalitarian systems of government.

(By the way, I don't use intelligentsia to refer to true intellectuals, but rather to the faux intellectuals; that is, those who may believe they're intellectuals, and who may even hold positions at academic and similar institutions, but whose quality of work if judged strictly on the merits is intellectually lacking to say the least. The true intellectuals may or may not hold any academic post or similar position. Indeed, given our homogenous or monolithic academic climate today, I doubt most true intellectuals do. Yet their work would be considered of the highest intellectual caliber or quality based on objective standards. As such, I use intelligentsia similar to how it was used by, for example, the Soviets, or how it is used by the present day Chinese Communist Party, who have displaced, sent into exile, or otherwise "disappeared" the true intellectuals, and substituted the true intellectuals with their intelligentsia. In fact, the true intellectuals in Russia before Lenin and the Russian revolution stood vehemently against the intelligentsia - Tolstoy, Dostoevsky, Chekhov, etc. Same with their predecessors like Pushkin who would have too. Indeed, Dostoevsky, for one, even predicted that a kind of Napoleonic "great man" or Nietzschan "will to power" or Melian "might makes right" mentality would possess many of his fellow Russians and lead to bloody revolution in his works The Possessed/The Demons, Crime and Punishment, and elsewhere.)

And some or many ID proponents have made this point in the past: it's not necessarily a fallacious slippery slope from evolutionary materialism to woke ideology to totalitarianism.

At the time, many found it almost laughable, or at least were utterly incredulous about the purported connection, but given the Zeitgeist of the West now, it's no longer a laughing matter, but very much a live possibility if not a high plausibility.

Alas! we live the Chinese curse of living in "interesting" times.

Expand full comment
20 more comments...

No posts