Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Vox Day's avatar

Thank you for the review, and also for the mathematical analysis by your distinguished guest.

I'd like to point out two things. First, I'm not critical of the ID creationists because I simply don't know very much about their arguments. My background is in economics and game design, and I came to the subject through criticizing the New Atheists, not through any interest or background in biology, evolution, or human origins. It was while reading all of Dawkins's books in preparation for my own 2009 book on atheism that I realized both he and Daniel Dennett were functionally innumerate. My subsequent discovery of the 1966 Wistar Symposium confirmed that this had always been the case for most of the leading evolutionary figures in biology ever since Darwin himself.

I strongly suspect that the ID critics of evolution are probably more or less right, because when something is completely false, there are many different ways to observe that. The difference between what I understand they're doing and what I'm doing is that they're mostly utilizing logical persuasion and I'm utilizing the much more conclusive method of math. You can handwave away logic with a pretty narrative and still be taken seriously, but it's a lot harder to do that when your numbers don't add up.

Second, I should point out that I've already released a second edition of PZ because in the first edition I was using outdated and incomplete numbers based on the 2005 genomic mappings. The 2025 Yoo et al study increased the total genetic gap that evolution needs to explain by a factor of 10; the observed genetic difference between chimp and human is now 410 million base-pairs, so it is very obvious to anyone who can do long division that evolution by natural selection is not only impossible, but obviously never happened because it could not have taken place.

The easiest way to understand the impossibility is to simply look at the reproductive limits of the various species in the context of the requirement for species-wide mutational fixation. That was really all that was ever needed to completely shut down the theory of evolution, whether by natural selection, neutral substitution, or a combination thereof. But, as we know, biologists don't do math.

If you'd like me to send you a copy of the second edition, and of THE FROZEN GENE which explores some of the problems that our better understanding of human genetics may have uncovered, just shoot me an email.

The Deuce's avatar

I find Vox Day interesting because he usually approaches problems in an extremely outside-the-box way.

In this case, he looked at the claims of naturalistic evolution without any of the qualitative concepts that the debate usually revolves around, such as the appearance of purpose, biological function, irreducible/specified complexity, consciousness, rationality etc, and instead asked the purely *quantitative* question of whether it's mathematically possible for naturalistic processes that can be mathematically modeled to have produced and spread the sheer number of genetic differences (without regard for what if any function they serve, irreducibly complex or not) that actually exist between humans and chimps in the time available, and found that there are not by many orders of magnitude.

FWIW, he recently looked into the equations governing genetic drift more closely, and found that when properly applied to populations with realistic generation times and population sizes, it's mathematically impossible for even a single mutation to fix by drift in the entire existence of a species with a reasonable lifespan and a population size large enough to prevent extinction by error catastrophe, so he plans to release another edition of "Probability Zero" in which the section on neutral mutation will be heavily revised: https://voxday.net/2026/09/11/do-try-to-keep-up-dennis/

One thing he did point out in the book is that appealing to the genetic drift of neutral mutations to account for the differences between humans and great apes (which is what most population geneticists resort to, mistakenly believing that this gives them a mathematical out), even if it weren't unworkable mathematically, is to credit all of the functional and phenotypical differences between humans and great apes to pure chance.

In truth, trying to explain new biological function via "natural selection" is logically just an appeal to pure chance as well, because a mutation being "beneficial" in a given accidentally-occurring environment has nothing whatsoever at all to do with its being beneficial towards the realization of some future function that doesn't exist yet. A mutation is no more likely by virtue of being "beneficial" to be useful for a new functional system than is a "neutral" or "deleterious" mutation. And in fact, as Mike Behe has shown, what makes a mutation "beneficial" is more often than not that it is *destructive* of some existing function that has become a liability in an organism's current environment.

But appealing to neutral theory to explain genetic differences gives away even the PRETEXT that the evolutionist is appealing to anything but pure chance to explain new biological features.

I don't think the average layman appreciates the sheer absurdity of the situation. It's bad enough when Darwinists appeal to "natural selection" as a sort of limitless deus ex machina that just magically gives them anything they want without any real explanation needed, but geneticists who are "in the know" mathematically (though not really, as Vox has shown) aren't even doing that. They are quite literally claiming that our bipedalism, our big and structurally advanced brains, language, abstract thought, mathematical ability, moral sense, religion - everything that has resulted in us developing philosophy and splitting the atom and going to the moon and building the Sistine Chapel and so forth - that all of it is quite literally pure happenstance.

When you appreciate this, you can kind of start to see why infinite multiverse theories are so attractive to a certain class of people. If you're trying to attribute all human endeavor to chance, you're going to need a whooooooole lot of chance to rationalize it. But as Vox has shown, the math doesn't work out for neutral theory anyway.

Vox Day rhetorically knocks biologists for tending to be mathematically illiterate (Darwin himself admitted to this, as Vox has pointed out), and I think he is justified in doing so, but I think the problem is significantly worse than that. Biologists as a whole tend to be quite poor at highly abstract reasoning in general, and their mathematical deficiency is just one facet of that.

Because of this deficiency, they have an extraordinary difficulty keeping logical distinctions distinct in their minds throughout a train of thought more than a couple syllogisms, resulting in sloppy thinking that goes back to Darwin himself and has been instrumental in the survival of his theory.

As many have pointed out, Darwin insisted that "natural selection" was nothing more than the blind, mechanistic, physical factors in the environment accidentally causing some organisms to die without reproducing more than others, but he frequently attributed powers to it and explanatorily invoked it in ways that required it to be a literal intelligent agent with intentions to make logical sense. He simply couldn't maintain real purpose and the subjective illusion of purpose as distinct categories in his mind, and constantly conflated them to make his theory seem coherent. Several of his contemporaries pointed this out to him, but he was a "vibes-based" thinker and just didn't seem to be able to truly grok the problem. His successors are like him in that regard, and this is responsible for biologists perpetuating his errors of thought, failing to understand how crazy it is to attribute advanced human characteristics to "spandrels" or neutral changes, and failing to understand the radically nominalist and deconstructionist implications of the naturalism they peddle for truth itself more broadly.

16 more comments...

Ready for more?